Page:The Journal of geology (IA journalofgeology11893univ).pdf/48
quainted with the true nature of the objects collected and discussed, and little skilled in the observation of the phenomena by means of which all questions of age must be determined, have undoubtedly made grievous mistakes and have thus misled an expectant and credulous public.
The articles themselves, the so-called gravel finds, when closely studied are found to tell their own story much more fully and accurately than it has heretofore been read by students of archeology. This story is that the art of the Delaware valley is to all intents and purposes a unit, that there is nothing unique or especially primitive or ancient and nothing un-Indian in it all. All forms are found on demonstrably recent sites of manufacture. The rude forms assigned by some to glacial times are all apparently "wasters" of Indian manufacture. The large blades of "Eskimo" type are only the larger blades, knives and spear points of the Indian, separated arbitrarily from the body of the art-remains to subserve the ends of a theory, certain obscure phenomena of occurrence having been found to give color to the proceeding. To place any part of this art, rude or elaborate, permanently in any other than the ordinary Indian category will take stronger proofs than have yet been developed in the region itself.
The question asked in the beginning, "Are there traces of glacial man in the Trenton gravels?" if not answered decisively in the negative, stands little chance, considering present evidence, of being answered in the affirmative. In view of the fact that numerous observations of apparent value have been made in other sections, there is yet sufficient reason for letting the query stand, and we may continue to cherish the hope that possibly by renewed effort and improved methods of investigation, something may yet be found in the Trenton gravels clearly demonstrative of the fascinating belief in a great antiquity for the human race in America.
The evidence upon which paleolithic man in America depends is so intangible that, unsupported by supposed analogies with European conditions and phenomena, and by the suggestions of