Page:The Journal of geology (IA journalofgeology11893univ).pdf/77
epoch from another. Changes of this sort have often furnished the basis for the major and minor divisions of time in other parts of geological history, so that there can be no question as to their adequacy, if they were of sufficient magnitude. We hold that the intervention of orographic or other important geologic changes might reduce to a minimum the amount of recession, the duration of the recession, and the warmth of the intervening climate necessary to constitute the separate ice advances separate ice epochs. The absence of great orographic or other changes in glaciated regions between successive advances of the ice would be no proof that such advances should not be regarded as separate epochs. Divisions of equal importance have often been made without evidence of such changes.
From the foregoing discussion, brief as it is, it will be seen that within certain narrow limits the definition of a glacial epoch, as distinct from other glacial epochs, must be more or less arbitrary. It is less important that an arbitrary definition should be accepted, than that the same meaning should be attached to technical terms in common use among geologists. In the interest of harmony and of a common understanding, and without the violation of any truth of science, we believe it would be well if the conception of a glacial epoch, as framed by those who are our leaders in position and in fact, were made the basis for our usage of the term.
III. The Criteria of Distinct Glacial Epochs.
If there have been differences of opinion concerning the nature of ice epochs, as distinct from each other and from ice periods, there has been a failure to adequately apprehend the nature, the extent, and the meaning of the real criteria on which the final recognition of separate ice epochs, if such there were, must be based.
Such criteria are several in number. They are of unequal value. In some instances a single one of them might be quite sufficient to establish the fact of two ice epochs. In other cases, single criteria which might not be in themselves demonstra-