Page:The World's Famous Orations Volume 3.pdf/203

This page needs to be proofread.

CHATHAM

I

THE RETORT TO WALPOLE^[1]

(1741)

Born in 1708, died in 1778; entered Parliament in 1735; attacked the Government in 1755, and removed from office; Secretary of State in 1756–1757; again Secretary of State in the Coalition Ministry of 1757–1761, when he adopted vigorous measures in the Seven Years' War; Prime Minister in 1766; resigned on account of ill health in 1768; made his last appearance in Parliament in 1778.

The atrocious crime of being a young man, which the honorable gentleman has, with such spirit and decency, charged upon me, I shall neither attempt to palliate nor deny; but content myself with wishing that I may be one of those whose follies may cease with their youth, and not

↑ This celebrated retort was made during the debate on Walpole’s bill for the encouragement and increase of seamen. As here given, it was furnished by Doctor Johnson to The Gentleman's Magazine for November, 1741. The phrasing of the retort in the main is undoubtedly Johnson’s rather than Pitt’s. Long after the date of the speech, some one mentioned it in Johnson's presence as superior to anything in Demosthenes, whereupon Johnson declared, "I wrote that speech in a garret in Exeter Street." The internal evidence bears him out, for in these reports Pitt, Walpole, Halifax, and Newcastle all speak alike. But the ideas are of course those of Pitt. The reply was not made to Sir Robert Walpole, the prime minister, but to his brother, Horace Walpole, the elder, who in answer to a speech Pitt had already made attacking Sir Robert's administration, had said:

"Formidable sound and furious declamation, confident assertions

193

[p193-1] This celebrated retort was made during the debate on Walpole’s bill for the encouragement and increase of seamen. As here given, it was furnished by Doctor Johnson to The Gentleman's Magazine for November, 1741. The phrasing of the retort in the main is undoubtedly Johnson’s rather than Pitt’s. Long after the date of the speech, some one mentioned it in Johnson's presence as superior to anything in Demosthenes, whereupon Johnson declared, "I wrote that speech in a garret in Exeter Street." The internal evidence bears him out, for in these reports Pitt, Walpole, Halifax, and Newcastle all speak alike. But the ideas are of course those of Pitt. The reply was not made to Sir Robert Walpole, the prime minister, but to his brother, Horace Walpole, the elder, who in answer to a speech Pitt had already made attacking Sir Robert's administration, had said:

"Formidable sound and furious declamation, confident assertions

[1]